Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Home
United States
Shelter Island

Town in Suffolk County, New York

Browse hotels, inns, motels, B&Bs and hostels in Shelter Island.

Want your hotel to be the top-listed hotel in Shelter Island, NY?

Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

The Pridwin Hotel

4.7 (762)

A

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island 11964

Hotel Resort

Directions

Kayak Shelter Island

B

Kayak Shelter Island

80 Burns Road, Shelter Island 11964

Call Directions

The Ram’s Head Inn

C

The Ram’s Head Inn

108 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island 11965

Hotel

Call Directions

Shelter Island Hideaway Vacation House

D

Shelter Island Hideaway Vacation House

1 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island 11964

Vacation Home Rental

Directions

The Candlelite Inn

E

The Candlelite Inn

3 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island 11964

Bed And Breakfast
Hotel

Call Directions

Hotels, inns and B&Bs

Resorts and lodges

Resorts

Vacation rentals and apartments

Vacation Home Rental

Show all categories

Nearby hotels