12/09/2026
The Guildhall
The Guildhall in St Ives occupies an important place in the history of the town. Its story reflects the way St Ives has changed from a medieval fishing community into a busy centre of commerce, civic life, art and culture.
The present Guildhall on Street an Pol was completed in 1939, but its story reaches much further back. Its history connects the modern building with the medieval Guildhall, the Market House and the changing civic life of the town.
The original Guildhall stood in the area now occupied by the Market House, outside the Church of St Ia. It dates from around 1490 and was the centre for the town's civic and commercial life at a time when St Ives was largely a fishing and maritime community. The building became connected with some of the most turbulent events in Cornish history. During the Prayer Book Rebellion of 1549, St Ives became involved in the wider uprising against the religious changes introduced during the reign of Edward VI. John Payne, the town's portreeve, was one of the leading local figures associated with the rebellion. When the uprising was defeated, he was arrested and executed in the Market Place, close to the Guildhall.
The old Guildhall survived for more than 300 years. By the 1820s, however, it had become outdated and was demolished. A new Market House was built on the site in 1832. The new building had several purposes. There was a market, a lock up for prisoners and an assembly room. The room above was used for civic meetings and later as a courthouse. In other words, the Market House continued the site's long connection with both commerce and local government.
The site of today's Guildhall has its own fascinating earlier history. Before the present Guildhall was built, the site was occupied by a Georgian mansion known as The Retreat. It was first associated with the Anthony family and later with the Lanham family. Artists had already been coming to the town during the nineteenth century, attracted by the scenery, the sea and the quality of the light. James Lanham established an art gallery at The Retreat, helping to lay the foundations for St Ives' later reputation as an artists' colony.
By the early twentieth century, St Ives had grown considerably and the Borough Council was finding its existing accommodation increasingly unsuitable. Its offices were spread across several buildings, including an old cottage on a small plot between The Retreat and the Vicarage. It was clear that the town needed a proper civic building, and plans were made for a new purpose-built Guildhall on Street an Pol. Local architect Geoffrey B Drewitt was chosen to design it, producing a building in the Neoclassical style, a style that was popular for British civic buildings at the time. The new Guildhall was completed in 1939, although the first council meeting did not take place there until 16 December 1940. Even today, some of the original character of the building can be seen as soon as you enter, with a fine 1930s terrazzo floor and staircase adding a touch of period style to the entrance.
Like many Neoclassical buildings, the Guildhall was designed around symmetry and proportion. Its original front had a central entrance reached by wide sweeping steps, flanked by elegant curved parapets, with a balcony and regular rows of windows above. The carefully cut stone gave the building a strong, formal appearance, with very little decoration. Instead, its character came from the shape of the building, the balance of its proportions and the solid quality of the stone. Sadly, this original appearance was altered when Cornwall Council removed one of the curved parapets and redesigned the steps to the entrance to make way for a much-needed accessibility ramp. In doing so, the foundation stone was buried beneath the new concrete. While the need for better access was welcomed, many people felt that the rather stark, functional design of the ramp was at odds with the elegance of the original building, and that a more sympathetic solution could have been found.
The choice of Neoclassical design is also interesting because the Guildhall was built in 1939, at a time when Modernism and Art Deco were already changing the look of British towns and cities. Classical architecture remained popular for civic buildings because it conveyed ideas of order, stability and permanence. The Guildhall therefore looked back to a much older tradition of public architecture, even as the modern world was changing around it. The contrast can still be seen nearby in the Royal Cinema, which also opened in 1939 but adopted the fashionable Art Deco style, with its emphasis on modern entertainment, movement and new technology. The Guildhall, by comparison, presented a much more traditional image of civic life, making the two buildings an interesting reflection of the different sides of St Ives at the end of the 1930s.
This was happening in a town that was also beginning to develop an international reputation for modern art.
The Guildhall was never intended to be just a council building. At the front were the council chamber, Mayor's Parlour, rates office and offices for council staff, while at the rear was a large auditorium designed for concerts, meetings and public events. From the beginning, the building brought civic administration and community life together under one roof. Opening its doors during the Second World War, the hall quickly became an important meeting place for local people, hosting dances, concerts, meetings and performances, social events that have remained an important part of the building's story. For much of the twentieth century, the Guildhall was the seat of St Ives Borough Council, but this changed in 1974 when local government was reorganised and St Ives ceased to be an independent borough, becoming part of the new Penwith District Council area. The Guildhall was no longer the main centre of local government for the wider district, although it continued to play an important role in the town. Over time, its focus shifted increasingly towards culture, entertainment and community life, with the auditorium becoming a venue for music, theatre, comedy, dancing, markets and local gatherings. It also became closely associated with the St Ives September Festival, which began in 1978, following its initial development in 1977, and grew into one of the town's best known cultural events.
The Guildhall's connection with art seems particularly fitting given the story of St Ives itself. During the twentieth century, the town became known around the world for artists such as Barbara Hepworth and Ben Nicholson, along with many others who helped shape the St Ives art scene and change the way the town was seen. The Guildhall has its own links to this history, with works connected to local artists including Robert Borlase Smart and Mary McCrossan inside the building, while outside stands Barbara Hepworth's bronze sculpture Dual Form, unveiled in 1966. It is an interesting contrast, the Guildhall's formal architecture belongs to an older tradition of civic buildings, while the art found within and around it connects the building to the bold and experimental artistic culture that made St Ives famous. In many ways, the Guildhall brings these two worlds together, the traditional civic life of St Ives and the modern St Ives a centre for British art.
Following the changes to local government in the 1970s, ownership of the Guildhall passed first to Penwith District Council then later to Cornwall Council. Today, following Cornwall Council's programme of devolving community assets, the Guildhall is once again owned and managed by St Ives Town Council. Its role has changed considerably since 1939, but its basic purpose remains much the same, it is still a place where people can meet, take part in community life, enjoy entertainment and, in the upper rooms, carry out the business of the town council. The building is now undergoing a major programme of renovation, aimed at securing its future while making it more accessible and better suited to modern audiences. The work includes improvements to seating, accessibility, technical and performance facilities, entrances, the foyer and other public spaces, while retaining as much of the building's original character as possible. The work has not been without its challenges, and some changes have had to be made along the way. Most noticeably, the remaining curved parapet at the front of the building has had to be removed as part of the works, leaving nothing of the Guildhall's original sweeping entrance stair. The hope is that, once the work is complete, the Guildhall will once again become a much loved and well used part of St Ives, with the Town Council currently expecting the renewed building to reopen in early 2027.
Photos: The Guildhall and the Market House