24/10/2026
An exorcism at a church in Lenton was said to have failed. The phantom at the centre of the story has come down to us without a name, without an identity, and with one oddly specific feature: a goatee.
THE MIDNIGHT CASE FILES
THE MAN WITH THE GOATEE
Lenton, Nottinghamshire
The story belongs to the Priory Church of St Anthony on Gregory Street, Old Lenton. During the mid-to-late twentieth century, the church was said to be haunted by a male figure with a goatee. An exorcism was reportedly performed at the site, but the attempt was said to have been unsuccessful.
That is the surviving outline. There is no precise year, no named witness and no account of what happened during the ceremony. The description preserves a detail someone might recognise on an ordinary passing stranger, yet almost everything that could tell us who he was has slipped away.
When I started looking into the church itself, I found a building whose history had already involved destruction, survival and a return from near ruin.
THE CHURCH THAT ALMOST DISAPPEARED
St Anthony’s stands beside the remains of Lenton Priory, a religious community founded before 1108. The present church is thought to incorporate parts of the chapel associated with the priory’s Hospital of St Anthony, described in the church history research as a charitable almshouse for men. It should not be confused with the much larger monastic church that once stood nearby.
The priory was dissolved in 1538. Its last prior, Nicholas Heath, whose name appears under several spellings, was executed. That gives the surrounding ground a troubled history, but I found nothing identifying him as the man with the goatee. His name belongs to the documented history; the phantom’s identity remains open.
Centuries later, the little church faced another upheaval. After the new Holy Trinity church opened in 1842, the old building was partly demolished. Its nave became a roofless shell. An old photograph shows ivy spreading across the broken remains, with the surviving chancel beside them. Yet worship continued or resumed in the chancel and vestry. Even while part of the church stood in ruins, people still gathered inside what remained.
THE NEWSPAPER THAT TAKES US BACK INSIDE
I found an original report in the Nottingham Evening Post dated 5 December 1884. Its subject was the restoration of Lenton Priory Church, and it recorded that the reopening services had begun the previous day.
Architects Evans and Jolley had transformed the surviving structure into a church capable of holding about 400 people. As much old walling as possible had been retained. Because the ground was damp, the wooden floor had been raised, leaving a ventilated space beneath it.
The report also preserves the smaller details of that opening day. Rain prevented the planned procession from the school to the church. The clergy had to robe in the vestry instead. A large congregation attended despite the weather, and the collection raised nearly £74, although around £220 was still needed to clear the restoration debt.
These are the things that bring the building back into focus: wet weather, crowded worshippers, old walls incorporated into new work. The church in the ghost story had already been taken apart and put back together.
WHAT SURVIVED WITHIN THE WALLS
There are older fragments still woven into its fabric. Medieval carving was reused in a sanctuary step. An archaeological account records a worn priest’s grave slab marked with a chalice and a book, and another medieval slab partly concealed behind the organ.
Outside, the churchyard contains family tombs and memorials, including the Stretton sarcophagus and the Wright family vault. Some older grave markers were moved against the boundary walls in 1949. These records give us names, dates and physical traces of people connected with the place. None supplies a supported identity for the apparition.
The photographs also preserve the church’s twentieth-century community: Sunday school children in 1948, parishioners giving donations, the choir gathered for a later opening. Ordinary moments from a place that carried an extraordinary story.
THE MISSING PART
The haunting account was entered into the Paranormal Database in May 2008, with its source described simply as published media. I have not yet traced the publication behind it, or a contemporary account of the alleged exorcism.
What stays with me is the word “unsuccessful”. It suggests there was some reason to judge the attempt a failure, but that reason is missing from the surviving telling.
At the church’s reopening in 1884, the Bishop of Southwell preached from a passage containing the words: “in this place will I give peace.”
Decades later, a story attached itself to the same church about a man who apparently could not be persuaded to leave.
Who decided the exorcism had failed—and what happened at St Anthony’s that made them say so?