10/06/2026
The Eddystone Series · Part Three of Six
Stone, fire and oak.
After Winstanley, a silk merchant named John Rudyard built the second lighthouse in 1709. He took a shipbuilder’s approach rather than an architect’s, designing a smooth conical tower that could shed the sea rather than fight it. It stood for forty-seven years.
On the night of 2 December 1755, a candle set the lantern roof alight. The keeper on watch was Henry Hall - ninety-four years old, and by all accounts still remarkably active. He fought the fire heroically, throwing buckets of water upward at the flames. As he looked up, molten lead from the roof poured into his mouth. He was rescued, but died twelve days later. The piece of lead recovered from his stomach is now in the National Museums of Scotland.
Then came John Smeaton. He modelled his new stone tower on the shape of an oak tree, broad and rooted at the base, tapering above, and invented hydraulic lime cement to hold the granite blocks together underwater. It was a revolution in engineering. His tower was lit in 1759 and stood for 120 years, until the rock beneath it began to crack.
Plymouth loved Smeaton’s tower so much that when it had to come down, the city paid to dismantle it stone by stone and rebuild it on Plymouth Hoe, where it still stands today in its red and white stripes - just across the Sound from Cawsand.