Hill Hall Hotel

10/23/2026

We knew these windows had to stay.

A little taller, a little wider.

Filling the rooms with light and warmth.

Framing the world outside for those looking out.

-

We’ve come a long way in a year or so.
It’s a favorite place of ours, the upper level of the High School building, walking the hallway to catch glimpses out to the world beyond.

📷 David Elliott

10/16/2026

The Pirates have kept a watchful eye since we first entered this once-academic space.

They were here long before us—as a mascot for the students and sports teams of the school—and we felt we’d be doing a disservice to scrub them from the memory of the building.

Their presence lingers in quiet, unexpected ways, one eye always open.

🏴‍☠️



📷 David Elliott

10/15/2026

It's fair to say we're biased about the charm of Fayetteville and the beauty of the the Gorge, but there's a welcome change of pace in this part of the world that can be hard to come by in a bigger city.

Come see (and more importantly, feel) Hill Hall for yourself this season, and let us provide your home base for adventures into the park and explorations of the history of Fayetteville.

Some of America’s most charming getaways are found in its smaller cities and towns—and these six new and newly renovated hotels offer another reason to visit this fall.

10/13/2026

The original sandstone building that once housed Fayetteville High School, has come a long way since renovations began.

The preservation of this property was not only for the students that once walked the halls, but in honor of those who first painstakingly laid these stones.

Those stonemasons, who arrived from Italy in the early 20th century, were some of the first settlers of Fayetteville. You’ll spot their handiwork around town if you look closely when walking around. Many of their descendants still live close by today.

-

Fun fact: Pulled from the Gorge itself, Nuttall Sandstone has the unique and delightful quality of appearing sparkly pink in a certain light!

💅

Swipe for some before and after’s of the exterior of the school.
📷 David Elliott

10/09/2026

There’s not a day that goes by that we don’t think about the thousands of students that once walked these hallways.

For over 75 years, these walls housed classrooms and science labs, lecture rooms and libraries. The Principal’s Office is now where our front desk staff greet you on arrival.

-

Our design team painstakingly transformed every space from the inside out — preserving the airy openness of the original buildings while adding textured layers of warmth to soften the scale of each room.

It’s a really beautiful end result, and we hope you think so too!

-

Words: Hospitality Design magazine 🗞️

📷 David Elliott

10/07/2026

Whether you’ve crept out of bed for a late night snack—Chex Mix pairs well with a nostalgic cozy-season movie—or you woke early to pack a few hunger-quenchers for your sunrise hike, our Provisions store aims to delight the visitor.

🍿

On the weekend you’ll find ᗯOOᗪ IᖇOᑎ EᗩTEᖇY burritos when you open your the warming oven, and every day you can help yourself to a cup of Cherry River Coffee Roasters fresh-brewed coffee.

📷 David Elliott

10/06/2026

"The design of Hill Hall pairs preserved schoolhouse architecture with warm, residential interiors, transforming the property into a gathering place for travelers and local residents alike."

Learn about the family history we honored, and see more of the design details that have been incorporated into the renovation of this historic property at the link below.

Thank you to Hospitality Design magazine for the feature!

Mountain Shore Properties opens Hill Hall Hotel, a 40-room boutique property in downtown Fayetteville, West Virginia.

10/06/2026