Hotel McArthur

Hotel McArthur Follow the renovation progress of historic Hotel McArthur in Vinton County, Ohio!

Post about the Hotel from 2014 in Unearthed Ohio.
06/15/2026

Post about the Hotel from 2014 in Unearthed Ohio.

06/14/2026

This is the text of the biography we posted on Hiram Hulbert. Hiram is the builder and original owner of Hulbert House which later became the Hotel McArthur. Built in 1839. Hopefully this will be easier to read form some!

Hiram Hulbert
Residence Year 1876
Residence Place Ohio, USA
Comments was born, September 2d, 1806, at Great Barrington, Massachusetts. He is the seventh of eight children born to Elisha Hulbert and Cloah Savage. His father was a native of Massachusetts and a farmer. Elisha Hulbert emigrated to Ohio in 1810, settling on the Big Hocking, seven miles from Athens, in the Ohio
Company's purchase, where he lived until his death in 1813. Hiram's mother was also born in Massachusetts and died in 1813. The subject of this sketch worked on a farm and attended school when he could until he was twenty years of age, at which time he had progressed so far as to be able to spell a few monosyllabic words. Leaving the farm he engaged to work for Daniel
Stewart, on the Hocking, thirteen miles from Athens--wages, three dollars a month. At the end of two months his employer thought his services worth more money, and accordingly advanced his wages to eight dollars per month. At the end of another month Hiram went on the Ohio river, and for forty days rowed on a keel boat, at the rate of nine dollars a month. In the latter part of
1826 he rowed a keel boat from Cincinnati to the mouth of the Kentucky river, making the trip in sixteen days, and receiving one dollar a day for his services. After this he returned to Athens, attended a common school for about six
months, learning to read, write and cipher as far as the rule of three. In 1827 young Hulbert went into a grocery store in Athens, remaining there six
months, at three dollars a month salary. But fortune had better things in store. He conceived the idea of peddling clocks about the country, and immediately set about it. He was so successful that in a few weeks he had made four hundred and fifty dollars clear of all expenses, in those days a small fortune for a young man. In this venture he had shown business tact and caution
which attracted the notice of his friends, who assisted him to start business on his own account. In June, 1830, he opened a store at McArthur, Vinton county. He started with a well-selected stock of goods, and immediately
began to do a good business. Since that time he has resided in McArthur, being engaged in business and prominently identified with the material growth of that place. He was in the grocery and dry-goods business until
1852, when he became involved in difficulties through his partner, and about all he had in the world was swept away. His friends came to his relief, and through their assistance he was able to buy back his property. He then went into the hotel business, carrying on a farm at the same time. His efforts to retrieve his loss were so successful that, in 1869, he paid the last dollar of his indebtedness, amounting to over nine thousand dollars. Mr. Hulbert was Captain, Quartermaster, and Adjutant in the 2d Division of the Ohio Militia under the old law. He is a Republican, but has never sought any office. For
forty years he has been a member of the Methodist Church. At the age of threescore years and ten, and after a life of industry and toil, Mr. Hulbert enjoys the use of his mental and physical faculties unimpaired. He is a leading and highly respected citizen of Vinton county.

An interesting biography on Hiram Hulbert. The first owner of what is now the Hotel McArthur.
06/13/2026

An interesting biography on Hiram Hulbert. The first owner of what is now the Hotel McArthur.

This may be the Hotel proprietor in 1900.Marion T. Allen
06/13/2026

This may be the Hotel proprietor in 1900.
Marion T. Allen

More research on the history of the hotel.In the 1920 Census the Head of the household shows  Eliza Stephenson. This can...
06/13/2026

More research on the history of the hotel.
In the 1920 Census the Head of the household shows Eliza Stephenson. This can only be made by assumption looking at the number of residents in the household. The listing of Hotel in the entry. And looking at all of the pages for McArthur in the 1920 census records.
In the 1910 Census it appears that Eliza's husband, Lewis Stephenson was the proprietor. This makes a possibility that he was the owner also. Research shows that Lewis died in 1913. This explains why he isn't listed in the 1910 census.

From our recent research. It appears that Katheryn Rutledge, who sold the Hotel to Paul Hogan in 1946. Was not managing ...
06/12/2026

From our recent research. It appears that Katheryn Rutledge, who sold the Hotel to Paul Hogan in 1946. Was not managing or residing at the Hotel in 1940. The photo is what appears to be the residents of the Hotel in the 1940 census. The manager at this time appears to be Alvin Lahman.

Did you know the Hotel was once the inspiration for a novel?
06/12/2026

Did you know the Hotel was once the inspiration for a novel?

This is a copy of the deed where Paul Hogan purchased the hotel on October 14, 1946. It was purchased from Katheryn and ...
06/11/2026

This is a copy of the deed where Paul Hogan purchased the hotel on October 14, 1946. It was purchased from Katheryn and Russell Rutledge. Our research shows the Rutledges living in Columbus at the time of the sale. The 1930 Census shows her as 29 years old and a hotel manager.
Story has it that Paul purchased the hotel in the middle of the night. He had one of the owners present at the Eagles.Another person was planning on purchasing the hotel the next day. With the help of some spirits ( alcohol) Paul made the purchase. At the Eagles in the middle of the night.
Our research continues and we appreciate any help that someone can give!

These are some photo captures from a video from the Hotel McArthur taken around 1990. The video has been enhanced and th...
06/10/2026

These are some photo captures from a video from the Hotel McArthur taken around 1990. The video has been enhanced and then some of the photos have been enhanced also. The Hotel has not always been an eyesore!

06/09/2026

As part of the renovation of the Hotel. We are looking for historic photos of McArthur to copy and place in the lobby. We would greatly appreciate any that people can share!

Address

101 E. Main Street
McArthur, OH
45651

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 4pm
Tuesday 8am - 4pm
Wednesday 8am - 4pm
Thursday 8am - 4pm
Friday 8am - 4pm

Telephone

+17405967077

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hotel McArthur posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Hotel

Send a message to Hotel McArthur:

Share

Category