10/20/2026
Elizabeth City, North Carolina — The Girl by the River
- Tim Flanagan
Sponsored by -
Holmes Automotive & Performance
Visit Norfolk
New Realm Brewing Co
Fairwood Lanes
Everyone in Elizabeth City knew the story of Nell Cropsey. More than a century earlier, the young woman had disappeared from her family’s waterfront home after stepping onto the porch one November night. Weeks later, her body was found in the Pasquotank River. A man was convicted, later pardoned, and the mystery never truly went away. Over the years, people began telling stories of a pale young woman seen near the old house, in upstairs windows, and along the river after dark. NC DNCR
Fifteen-year-old Caleb Warren had heard the story countless times, but he never believed the ghost part. That changed one chilly October evening when he and his cousin Mia stayed too late downtown after a Halloween event. They decided to walk part of the waterfront before heading home, joking about how perfect the fog looked for one of Elizabeth City’s famous ghost stories.
The Pasquotank was almost completely still. Lights from across the water shimmered on the surface while a thin layer of mist drifted above it. Caleb was taking a picture when Mia suddenly grabbed his arm.
“There’s somebody down there.”
A girl stood near the river.
She wore a long pale dress and faced the water with her back toward them. Caleb assumed she was part of some Halloween performance until he noticed something strange. Her clothing did not move in the breeze.
“Hey!” he called.
The girl slowly turned.
Her face was pale and terribly sad.
Then she lifted one hand and pointed toward the river.
A splash broke the silence.
Caleb shined his flashlight across the water. For an instant he thought he saw another figure standing several yards offshore, impossibly upright on the surface. Then the fog rolled across it and the shape disappeared.
When Caleb looked back, the girl was walking away.
“Wait!”
He and Mia followed.
She moved along the waterfront without making a sound, always staying twenty or thirty feet ahead. At the end of the walkway she stopped beneath an old tree.
Then she whispered one word.
“Find.”
Before Caleb could ask what she meant, the girl vanished.
Not walked away.
Vanished.
Mia wanted to leave immediately, but Caleb noticed something lying where the girl had stood. It was a small metal locket, dark with age.
The next morning they took it to Caleb’s grandmother, who had lived in Elizabeth City her entire life. The moment she saw it, her expression changed.
She retrieved an old newspaper reproduction about Nell Cropsey and pointed to a photograph.
Around Nell’s neck was a small oval locket.
It looked almost identical.
Caleb felt cold.
“That can’t be hers.”
His grandmother shook her head.
“Probably not. But Elizabeth City has been telling stories about Nell for generations. Sometimes history and folklore get tangled together until nobody knows where one ends and the other begins.”
That evening Caleb returned to the waterfront with his grandmother. He placed the locket beside the river.
For several minutes nothing happened.
Then a young woman appeared through the fog.
She looked at Caleb.
This time she smiled.
Behind her, something dark moved beneath the surface.
The smile disappeared.
Nell pointed toward it.
And whispered:
“Not me.”
Then the river suddenly churned.
Caleb stepped backward as the girl faded into the mist.
The locket was gone.
To this day, Caleb does not know what he saw on the Pasquotank. He only knows that he never again laughed when someone mentioned Elizabeth City’s ghosts.
Because sometimes the dead do not return to frighten us.
Sometimes they return because there is still something they want us to know.
For everything fun visit our magazine at the link below...
https://www.whatshappeningentertainment.com
